Testing, Miri, and Final Checklist

🧭 Chapter 10 — Lessons Learned & What’s Next

“We rebuilt a wheel. now we understand axles, roads, and why it’s round.”

10.1 what Vec taught us

  • ownership at the metal: you must model who owns what at every instant.
  • three numbers rule: ptr, len, cap + strict invariants.
  • unsafe doesn’t mean unsound: with the right guards, you can recover safely from panics.
  • abstraction layering: RawVec (allocation) vs Vec (initialization & logic).
  • iteration & slices are borrow-projections: lift raw memory into safe references only when invariants guarantee correctness.

10.2 common footguns (and the antidotes)

footgun antidote
drop uninitialized memory tie drops strictly to [0..len)
double-drop on pop/into_iter use ptr::read, and consume/forget original owner
lost pointer on failed realloc write to temp, only commit on success
panic mid-mutation scope guards that roll back len and drop newly inited items
aliasing &mut during iteration hand each slot out once, no overlap

10.3 where we go next (your series roadmap)

You said your blog will also cover Box, Rc, NonNull, Unique, HashMap. here’s a crisp sequence and the promise of each:

  1. Box<T> — Owning a Single Allocation

    • Build minimal Box on top of alloc/dealloc.
    • Move semantics, Box::leak, into_raw/from_raw.
    • Niche optimization: ZSTs and non-null guarantees.
  2. NonNull<T> — Raw Pointer With a Contract

    • Why Option<NonNull<T>> is niche-optimized (no extra space).
    • Using NonNull to encode “never null” and enable niche layouts.
    • Powering custom containers without *mut T footguns.
  3. Unique<T> (a la internal std concepts)

    • Encoding unique ownership + provenance for aliasing rules.
    • How this informs optimizer assumptions for Vec, Box.
  4. Rc<T> — Shared Ownership & Refcounts

    • Single-threaded refcounting; weak refs; cycle pitfalls.
    • Layout: [refcnt][weakcnt][T] and pointer casting.
    • Panic safety when cloning/decay to Weak.
  5. HashMap<K,V> — Associative Power

    • allocation + probing (Robin Hood / SwissTable sketch).
    • Hash, BuildHasher, DoS safety.
    • growth policy, tombstones, and rehashing guards.
    • iterators over buckets and panic-safe rehash.

⚠️ each chapter will keep the same read-like sidenotes, warnings, and diagrams, with progressively richer invariants.


10.4 final word

you didn’t just implement a vector — you built an intuition for why Rust’s safety model works and how to extend it beyond the standard library.

“unsafe is a scalpel — in careful hands, it heals.”


if you want, i can now spin this into publish-ready blog posts (mdx or markdown), including:

  • a compact crate layout (myvec/) with tests & benches,
  • diagrams (ascii + mermaid),
  • “try it” snippets and cargo commands.

or we can start the next book in the series right away — which one do you want first: Box, NonNull, Unique, Rc, or HashMap?